Quartz vs. granite countertops comes down to one trade: quartz is an engineered surface that its makers say never needs sealing, while granite is a natural stone with patterns no factory can repeat, and it may benefit from sealing. Both are hard, durable worktops, and both want a trivet under a hot pan. Which one is right depends on how your kitchen is used and how much natural variation you want to live with.
Quartz is what most of the worktops we install are made of, and we also supply and install natural stone, including granite, marble and quartzite. So we have no reason to push one over the other. Here is how they compare, with every material fact linked to the manufacturer or stone authority that states it.
What quartz countertops are made of
Quartz countertops are a manufactured product. MSI, which makes the Q Premium line we carry, describes quartz as a man-made product, roughly 93 to 95 percent quartz and 5 to 7 percent resin by weight, with the resin a polymer mix. Because it is manufactured, the color and pattern are the maker’s design rather than the quarry’s.
Because the pattern is designed, quartz is often chosen for a calmer, more predictable look. That does not mean every slab is identical. Cambria’s product care page notes that samples are small cuts from a larger slab and may not show all the design characteristics of the installed product, and that seams are visible. That is one reason we would rather you saw material at full size in the Anaheim showroom than judged it from a chip.
Granite is a natural stone, quarried and cut into slabs. The Natural Stone Institute’s consumer site explains that granite is a category of rock that forms from liquid magma, and that visually it has distinct flecks of darker colors. Every slab is different, which is the whole appeal for some people and a worry for others.
The same source notes that granite is harder than glass and is not etched by everyday kitchen acids such as lemon juice or vinegar. That separates it from marble, which does etch. The Natural Stone Institute also says that many granites receive a resin treatment at the factory to fill micro-fissures and small natural “birth marks” before the slab is polished.